Manga vs Realisim

4 min read

Deviation Actions

CooroJaden's avatar
By
Published:
4.8K Views
I personally have no issue with either, though I do prefer realistic art. Manga is always pleasant to view as well, though.
But something(actually many somethings) brought something of a clash between the two styles.

A dear friend(of whom I will not name)'s father seems to think manga is a bad thing, and can't tell the difference between the styles.
The following will be me addressing the flawed opinions this person seems to have developed.


Differentiate


First, lets assess what the manga or anime-style is like.

The father was shown a group's gallery of foxes, to which he said they were all like anime(even my own art, which kindof led me to do this). 
I can't speak for others but I can speak for BuryTheMaid(another person whose art was falsely labeled) and myself when I say he is quite mistaken.

While anime people and more realistic people are usually easily distinguished between themselves, animals are often not, and have many different styles and these are just a few.


Side-Character Animals

These anime canines usually consist of a round head, two beady eyes, and a small snout with a little cutie smile, like so;


Little facial detail and basic general-shape anatomy. Still cute tho.


Ginga Densetsu Weed Animals

Bulbous anatomy, boxy paws, boxy snout, and wide human eyes, like so;

don't piss it off tho
Hate the style, love the anime.


Fruits Basket Animals

Little to no detail with minimal shading and near lifeless eyes.


Again, hate the style, love the anime.



Princess Mononoke Animals

A sound amount of detail, gorgeous animation, though human-like eyes.




Wolf's Rain Animals

A sound amount of detail, iffy anatomy at times, as animation is hard work.

and can you believe it? ITS ANIME! :U



THESE ARE ANIME ANIMALS



Acceptance


Manga and anime alike have specific goals throughout their works, set in the very first episode or pages.
Some are made to be beautiful and creative while others are meant to tell a story and enlighten you with interesting plot-twists and thought-provoking events.
Some series are simply not designed to look photo-realistic like you seem to want them to look(plus it would make it vastly more difficult to produce).

These pieces are not more or less, but simply different and shouldn't be persecuted for their beloved creativity.

It is admirable that you wish your daughter to advance in her talent, but to enforce your own preferences onto her is simply pressuring and stressful.
Find out her own quest before simply laying one out to her.
If she seeks to draw photo-realistically, point out anatomy flaws and offer constructive criticism rather than simply saying "Eh, it looks like some anime shit.".
If she wants to draw a similar style to anime, then let her do so. As I said, it is not less, it is not more, it is only a different style from what you like. Simply. Different.

And there is plenty of time to allow her to explore all the many possibilities.



Personal Experiences


Now, this friend of mine isn't alone in this;


-My own dad often points out that my work is similar to anime and manga styles, to which I blatantly disagree.

-My dad had taken me to a comic book store to display some of my more detailed works and before this man even looked at my drawing he went on to assure me that manga like kingdom hearts and such is 'in'(to which made me angry for the next couple days).

What about you? Anyone else's art been falsely labeled?
© 2014 - 2024 CooroJaden
Comments2
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
BuryTheMaid's avatar
It just pisses me off that the entire spectrum of anime (which, in my opinion is not a straight-cut thing, but more of a fluid group of similarities between artists) is always lumped together as one collective thing. Some anime styles are extremely exaggerated or deformed which may or may not be pleasing to the viewer, which is completely fine. Some people dislike Picasso and that's perfectly fine. Art styles are what make artists unique from one another. Styles are what the artist is comfortable with, not necessarily catered specifically to their audience. Not everyone is going to be satisfied anyway.

I personally dislike a lot of American style cartoons myself. Many of them (despite enjoying the shows themselves - ie Ed, Edd, and Eddy, Rugrats, As Told by Ginger, Wild Thornberries, Rocko's Modern Life, Ren and Stimpy, The Simpsons, etc) are what I would consider to be ugly and yet no one criticizes them. At least not to the same degree as anime so often is.

I could come up with some guesses as to why this is, but regardless it comes back to the same thing: art styles vary and not everyone likes them. So as an artist I think it's important to focus on what makes you happy. Being forced to use a style you don't like isn't going to make you enjoy it. (Though I do believe that branching out and trying new things is also important, and I'm in no way knocking realism. Just not when it's forced.)

I hope this makes sense, I'm on mobile ugh. Apologies for typos.